MapTools
D3 (d3-geo)
vs
Protomaps

D3 (d3-geo): Map projections and SVG maps for custom data graphics. Protomaps: Self-host an entire world basemap as a single PMTiles file.

D3 (d3-geo)Protomaps
CategoryMap Libraries & SDKsBasemaps & Map Tiles
Pricing modelOpen sourceOpen source
Starts atFreeFree
Free tier——
Open sourceYesYes
Software licenceISCBSD-3-Clause (code); ODbL (OSM data)
API——
PlatformsJavaScriptWeb, JavaScript, Command line
Made by——
Commercial useAllowedAllowed
Export / print imagesAllowedAllowed
Offline / cachingAllowedAllowed
Visits from MapTools19
Visit Visit

D3 (d3-geo) features

  • Many map projections
  • SVG and canvas rendering
  • TopoJSON support
  • Full design control
D3 (d3-geo) alternatives

Protomaps features

  • PMTiles single-file tile archives
  • Daily world basemap builds from OpenStreetMap
  • Serve from S3, R2 or any static host
  • Open basemap styles for MapLibre

When you host the tiles yourself, only the OpenStreetMap attribution and ODbL terms apply.

Protomaps alternatives

Summary based on public information. Check each provider's current pricing and terms.